Price Reduced 8.28%

$665,000 ($310.02 per sqft)

Est. Mortgage $3,232/mo *

Quick Pre-Approval

Price History

$725,000
6/11/2025

$695,000
12/4/2025

$675,000
4/23/2026

$665,000
5/12/2026


1250 County Route 351, Rensselaerville, (Preston Hollow), NY, 12471

1250 County Route 351, Rensselaerville, (Preston Hollow), NY, 12471

11 rooms

4 beds

1 Full / 1 Half baths

1890

Colonial, Farmhouse

2,145 sqft

Historic Federal-Era Village Home in Picturesque Rensselaerville Nestled within the expansive Hyuck Nature Preserve, Rensselaerville is a pristine White Pine village dating to circa 1820, renowned for its stunning historic homes and natural beauty. The Preserve offers miles of managed trails, a breathtaking 300-foot waterfall (plus a hidden cascade), and exclusive summer swimming and boating memberships for residents—with lifeguards and lessons for children. Its ecological research center hosts seasonal nature programs, focusing on local flora, wildlife, and aquatic life. The vibrant village community centers around Conkling Hall, a cultural hub for music, theater, yoga, and Pilates. Nearby, the village boasts a community food store, restaurant, library, and year-round events and galas that celebrate local arts and fellowship. Since the pandemic, Rensselaerville has attracted a thriving community of artists and like-minded residents. Surrounded by state nature trails, it’s an ideal destination for hikers, bird watchers, and dog walkers, with supermarkets conveniently located in Greenville and New Scotland. Set on 11.8 lush acres, this historic home benefits from serene walking trails, streams, and ponds that attract diverse wildlife and birds. The gardens feature abundant perennials, expansive lawns, fragrant honey locust and black walnut trees—creating a tranquil, Eden-like summer retreat. An organic vegetable garden lies just above the house, maintained with sustainable practices. Built around 1820 during the village’s heyday as a felt-making center powered by nearby waterfalls and white pine forests, this home once served as the town apothecary—digging here has unearthed fascinating relics. Designed to capture natural light throughout the day with classic 8-over-8 mullioned sash windows and double exposures, it was meticulously restored by the historic specialist behind The Thomas Cole House. Original “witches hat” door hardware, period fireplaces, and wide-board white pine floors grace the living rooms, preserving the authentic charm of this exquisite Federal-era residence.


Status:

Active

Town:

Rensselaerville

Type:

Single-family residential

Heating:

Forced Air

Cooling:

None

Basement:

Unfinished, Walk-Out Access

Parking:

4-car

Acreage:

11.8

Est. Taxes:

$6,129

Assessment

$119,155

Construction

Frame

Utilities

Electricity Connected, Phone Connected, Sewer Connected, Water Connected

Lot Description:

Landscaped

View Description:

Panoramic

Waterfront:

Yes

Elementary School:

Berne-Knox-Westerlo Elem Sch

Middle School:

Berne-Knox-Westerlo Junior-Senior Hs

High School:

Berne-Knox-Westerlo Junior-Senior Hs

School District:

Berne-knox-westerlo

Days on Market:

334

Appliances:

Dishwasher, Dryer, Gas Range, Refrigerator, Washer

MLS #:

873203


Community Info

School Info

Walk Score

Mass Transit

Yelp



Listing courtesy of Four Seasons Sothebys Intl 518-822-0800