17 S Geneva Ct, Montauk, NY, 11954

Tucked away on a peaceful road, this cozy, plant-filled cottage offers the ideal home base for your Montauk getaway. Whether you're here for golf or tennis, you'll be just around the corner from the Montauk Downs. Beach lovers will appreciate being just a mile from Ditch Plains, a quick two-mile ride into town, or a short trip to the harbor for a boating adventure. Originally an Old Montauk Highway cottage, this special 2-bed, 2-bath home was relocated in the 1980s and thoughtfully updated over the years. Siding, roof, and deck updated in 2025. Filled with character and care, it's a beloved retreat that blends vintage charm with modern comfort. Perfect for families, enjoy the spacious backyard complete with outdoor dining, a fire pit, and a play structure for the kids. Available monthly, seasonally or year-round!