32 E Park Ave, Saint Augustine, FL, 32084 | $769,000

Nestled along the marsh in the heart of historic Fullerwood Park, this one-of-a-kind cottage and guest house offer privacy, character, and breathtaking views at the quiet end of East Park Avenue, just moments from San Marco Avenue and downtown St. Augustine. Thoughtfully elevated in 2020 to preserve its original architectural integrity, followed by extensive renovations completed in 2022, this distinctive property combines timeless craftsmanship with modern functionality. Positioned high above the surrounding homes, the residence enjoys panoramic marsh views, abundant natural light, refreshing sea breezes, and fully accessible storage beneath the home—perfect for bikes, kayaks, tools, and outdoor gear. The main house offers nearly 1, 500 square feet of living space with two bedrooms and one full bath, while the detached guest house provides more than 600 square feet with one bedroom and one full bath. The exterior restoration showcases original heart pine lap siding, cedar shake accents custom ship-inspired windows and vents, and a charming wide-plank privacy fence featuring dual arched entrances. An enchanting outdoor shower, inspired by Indonesian design and built around a mature tree, offers hot and cold water for year-round enjoyment. Inside, the light-filled main home is rich with character, featuring a barrel-vaulted living room ceiling, an original Craftsman fireplace preserved during the lift, custom-built dining room bookcases, generous trim details, and a thoughtful blend of vintage and contemporary lighting. The kitchen embraces a clean, timeless aesthetic with white shaker cabinetry, a gray mosaic tile backsplash, and a gas range. Upstairs, the spacious second bedroom offers flexibility for multiple uses and provides potential space for the addition of a second bathroom. Two enclosed porches serve as comfortable year-round living spaces, including a marsh-facing rear sunroom that captures cooling coastal breezes and a front all-season room completed in 2021. The detached guest house enjoys its own private marsh-facing deck and versatile living arrangement. Cottage has successfully served both visiting family and friends as well as traveling professionals, generating rental income of approximately $2, 000 per month through furnished finder. Enhancing the property's appeal is an additional one-third lot on the west side, creating an exceptionally spacious and private setting. This extra space also allows for a second curb cut and future driveway access. Two separate 30-amp electrical services have been installed on either side of the property, ideal for RVs, travel trailers, or other recreational uses. Solar panels for low FPL bill even in summer. For outdoor enthusiasts, a public kayak and paddleboard launch awaits at the end of the street, offering direct access to the waterways leading to downtown St. Augustine, the Castillo de San Marcos, and beyond. A truly rare opportunity to own a beautifully restored historic property with guest accommodations, income potential, and an unmatched marshfront lifestyle.

Features