37 Notch View Rd., Lexington, NY, 12468 | $1,950,000

There are properties you visit, and properties that stay with you. The view from this property is the kind that makes you stop mid-sentence. A sweeping, uninterrupted panorama directly into one of the Catskills' most dramatic mountain passes, framed by steep ridgelines that change with every season and every hour of light.

Whether imagined as a multigenerational family compound, a shared ownership retreat, or a property with serious hospitality potential, 37 Notch View Road is ready to become whatever its next owner dreams.

Set on five private acres with direct adjacency to approximately 23 acres of permanently protected NYC DEP watershed land, the privacy here is absolute and guaranteed. It will never change.

At 7, 000 square feet across three full levels, with four legal bedrooms, six bathrooms, and six additional flex rooms, this is not a house. It is a compound. The great room announces the scale immediately: vaulted ceilings, a massive stone wood-burning fireplace, hardwood floors, and the kind of volume that makes a large group feel entirely at home. The kitchen and dining room are generous and designed for gathering. Upstairs, the primary suite has a wing of its own, and the additional bedrooms are well-proportioned and private. The current owners have completed thoughtful updates throughout, including fully renovated bathrooms featuring distinctive Italian anthracite radiators, rebuilt decks and stairs, and plush carpeting throughout the bedrooms.

The lower level is its own world. A second living room, full bar, recreation room, and pellet stove, with walk-out access to the grounds.

Outside, a large wraparound deck captures every bit of that mountain view. There is a swimming and fishing pond, a fire pit with seating, a gazebo, and a separate outbuilding with a private bar and recreation space, ideal for casual entertaining or hobbies away from the main house. A three-car garage with loft storage completes it.

Minutes to Windham, Hunter, Belleayre, and Plattekill, with four-season outdoor recreation at your doorstep. Under three hours to New York City.

Features