500 Seagate Ln, Saint Augustine, FL, 32084 | $2,400,000

Nestled at the end of the cul de sac of Seagate Lane South in North Beach, this oceanview two-story home offers a rare blend of comfort, style, and exceptional potential for redevelopment. Built in 2000 and set on an acre of land, the property boasts over 3, 690 square feet of finished living space perfect for multigenerational living or investment opportunity. In addition to the spacious interior, the home features open porches, a third floor roof deck, and an oversized three-car garage. A long private driveway winds past mature tree canopies and a fenced-in pool with a pavered patio surround, creating a private coastal retreat. The first floor unit has its own front entry and is set up as a separate apartment that welcomes you with 2 bedrooms, a full bathroom, and an open kitchen with dining and living area that open out to a back patio space and fenced yard. Inside the unit, you have access to the spacious garage, as well as interior stairs that can be opened up or locked off to the main house upstairs. The second floor has its own grand entry and the main home opens into a tiled main entrance with an open-concept living area, and stunning ocean views. The French doors, flanked by large windows, lead to a spacious open deck with a third floor walkup to the viewing tower for panoramic views of the shoreline and intracoastal waterway. This upper level features a split floor plan with 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, an office, and an expansive kitchen space with an extended cabinet system into an eat-in kitchen with glass-front displays, and a breakfast nook. A dedicated separate dining area and a well-equipped laundry room with ample storage add everyday convenience. The owner’s suite is a peaceful haven with French doors opening onto the deck, a large bathroom with double vanities, a walk-in shower, and a soaking tub. Practical amenities include a gas fireplace, whole-house gas generator, electric & gas heater on pool, a roof replaced approx 4 years ago, newer windows, and a septic system that was pumped approx two years ago. The property falls under RG-1 zoning with a future land use designation of Residential Coastal (Res-C), allowing up to four units per acre. Neighboring parcels have capitalized on this potential with four townhomes each. This lot may be subdivided to accommodate an additional main dwelling or, without subdivision, an accessory family unit can be added—confirmed in writing by St. Johns County (attached in documents). Located just behind the oceanfront row of homes on a quiet street, this rare offering combines immediate coastal living with long-term development potential—ideal for a family retreat, an investment, or both.

Features