New Listing - 05/21/2026

$649,990 ($466.95 per sqft)

Est. Mortgage $3,160/mo *

Quick Pre-Approval

Brochure

Call Text Schedule Tour Request More Information

57 Wantagh Avenue, East Islip, NY, 11730

57 Wantagh Avenue, East Islip, NY, 11730
View larger map Directions

7 rooms

4 beds

3 Full baths

1954

Exp Cape

1,392 sqft

Welcome to 57 Wantagh Avenue in East Islip — a beautifully maintained expanded Cape offering the perfect blend of space, comfort, and functionality. This 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home features a flexible layout designed for today’s lifestyle. The spacious and sun-filled living room flows effortlessly into the formal dining room, creating the perfect setting for entertaining and everyday living. The updated kitchen and bathrooms add modern style and convenience throughout the home. The desirable main-level primary suite offers privacy and comfort with its own private bathroom, while three additional bedrooms upstairs and another full bath provide plenty of room. A full basement offers endless possibilities for recreation, storage, or additional living space. Step outside to enjoy the beautifully sized backyard, perfect for entertaining, relaxing, or creating your own outdoor retreat. Ideally located in the renowned East Islip School District, this expanded Cape is a wonderful opportunity to enjoy spacious Long Island living in a prime location.

Status:

Active

Type:

Single-family residential

Laundry Remarks:

In Basement

Heating:

Forced Air, Oil

Cooling:

Wall/Window Unit(s)

Basement:

Finished, Partial

Parking:

Driveway, Private

Acreage:

0.19

Est. Taxes:

$12,288

Assessment

$38,500

Construction

Frame

Utilities

Cable Available, Electricity Available, Water Available

Lot Description:

Back Yard

Elementary School:

Timber Point Elementary School

Middle School:

East Islip Middle School

High School:

East Islip High School

School District:

East Islip

Days on Market:

1

Appliances:

Dishwasher, Dryer, Gas Range, Refrigerator, Washer, Oil Water Heater

MLS #:

1003106

Community Info

School Info

Walk Score

Mass Transit

Yelp

Similar Properties

$640,000

5 beds

2 baths

1,822 sqft

50 Bayview Avenue, East Islip, NY, 11730

$635,000

3 beds

3 baths

1,612 sqft

45 Beecher Avenue, East Islip, NY, 11730

$679,900

3 beds

2 baths

1,368 sqft

31 Baldwin Street, East Islip, NY, 11730

$674,999

4 beds

1.5 baths

1,800 sqft

32 Lodge Lane, E. Setauket, (East Setauket), NY, 11733

Price Reduced!

$680,000

6 beds

2 baths

1,794 sqft

38 Moffitt Boulevard, East Islip, NY, 11730

$675,000

4 beds

2 baths

1,836 sqft

12 Branch Lane, E. Setauket, (East Setauket), NY, 11733

$649,999

3 beds

1 baths

1,260 sqft

138 E Madison Street, East Islip, NY, 11730

$599,000

4 beds

1 baths

1,470 sqft

3259 Union Boulevard, East Islip, NY, 11730

$625,000

3 beds

1 baths

1,542 sqft

7 Gerhardy Court, East Islip, NY, 11730

$699,000

3 beds

1 baths

1,270 sqft

50 Atlantic Avenue, East Islip, NY, 11730

Price Reduced!

$699,000

3 beds

2 baths

1,533 sqft

11 Jackson Street, East Islip, NY, 11730

$599,000

3 beds

1.5 baths

1,290 sqft

5 Washington Avenue, East Islip, NY, 11730

$699,000

4 beds

3 baths

2,200 sqft

30 Lodge Lane, E. Setauket, (East Setauket), NY, 11733

$599,000

2 beds

1.5 baths

1,464 sqft

56 Gwendolyn Place, East Islip, NY, 11730

$599,009

2 beds

1 baths

1,045 sqft

9 Brook Place, East Islip, NY, 11730

$699,999

3 beds

2 baths

3,116 sqft

3250 Sunrise Highway, East Islip, NY, 11730

New or Coming Soon Properties

Coming Soon!

$679,999

4 beds

2 baths

1,264 sqft

8 Wantagh Avenue, East Islip, NY, 11730

New Listing!

$595,000

2 beds

1 baths

840 sqft

45 Chester Street, E. Northport, (East Northport), NY, 11731

New Listing!

$669,000

3 beds

1.5 baths

1,831 sqft

107 Bellecrest Avenue, E. Northport, (East Northport), NY, 11731

New Listing!

$669,000

3 beds

3 baths

1,118 sqft

180 Park Avenue, Deer Park, NY, 11729

New Listing!

$699,000

5 beds

4 baths

2,424 sqft

19 Oak Street, Deer Park, NY, 11729

New Listing!

$649,999

4 beds

2 baths

2,200 sqft

179 Gnarled Hollow Road, E. Setauket, (East Setauket), NY, 11733

New Listing!

$699,000

2 beds

1 baths

1,452 sqft

179 Dix Hills Road, Dix Hills, NY, 11746

New Listing!

$649,999

3 beds

2 baths

1,727 sqft

11 Hollow Oak Drive, E. Patchogue, (East Patchogue), NY, 11772

$669,000

3 beds

2 baths

930 sqft

410 3rd Avenue, E. Northport, (East Northport), NY, 11731

New Listing!

$599,990

3 beds

1.5 baths

2,160 sqft

54 College Hills Drive, Farmingville, NY, 11738

New Listing!

$625,000

3 beds

1 baths

1,478 sqft

5 Thorpe Lane, East Islip, NY, 11730

Coming Soon!

$649,000

3 beds

1.5 baths

1,362 sqft

170 W 9th Street, Deer Park, NY, 11729

New Listing!

$599,999

3 beds

1.5 baths

1,078 sqft

4 Olive Court, Farmingville, NY, 11738

New Listing!

$649,998

4 beds

2.5 baths

2,292 sqft

14 Basswood Lane, Farmingville, NY, 11738

$699,990

3 beds

2 baths

1,650 sqft

6 Canterbury Court, E. Setauket, (East Setauket), NY, 11733

Coming Soon!

$699,999

3 beds

2 baths

2,200 sqft

262 W 9th Street, Deer Park, NY, 11729


Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate 631-589-8500