Custom Elite Agent Image

About Neagle Caffrey Team

Luxury Properties Specialist - Scituate Office
161 Front Street, Scituate, MA 02066
Cell: 781.603.9763

Connect with me:

linkedin Instagram Youtube

Official Real Estate Company of the Boston Red Sox

Our Team is proudly comprised of lifelong South Shore residents. As a multi-generational family team, we work cohesively to bring our clients exceptional service, clear communication and targeted marketing that delivers results when buying or selling real estate.

We attribute our success to the family foundation our group was built on. Our team dynamic resonates with clients because we each bring our own set of skills to the table. We offer a premiere level of service by balancing decades of market intelligence and established relationships with innovative digital marketing strategies that today's buyers and sellers are looking for. Most importantly, the family line is very much carried over in our day-to-day operations. That support, sounding board and approachability is what keeps our clients happy and coming back with their families.


Over $38 Million in Sales for 2020
Platinum Club 2020
Over $24 Million in Sales for 2019
Chairman's Elite Club 2019
Top Producing Team
Top Team in Closed Units
Top Producing Team for Luxury Properties

Over $32 Million in Sales for 2018
#10 Team In Massachusetts, 2018
#1 Listing Agents in Units in the town of Scituate for 2018
#1 Selling Agents in Volume and Units in the town of Scituate for 2018

Over $29 Million in Sales for 2017
#1 Listing Agents in Units in the town of Scituate for 2017
#1 Selling Agents in Volume and Units in the town of Scituate for 2017

Platinum Club 2018, 2020

Chairman's Elite Club 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2019

Top Producing Team 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019

Tops In Listings 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019

Excellence In Customer Service Award

Luxury Properties Specialist

Top Producing Agents in Scituate since 2011 with Volume over $109 million in Sales

Professional Specialty

The Neagle Caffrey Team provide superior real estate services to buyers and sellers located along Boston's south shore, from first-time home buyers to luxury property sales. Contact us today to hear how our family can help find your family's next home.

Sales Vice President

Platinum Club


New Construction

First Time Home Buyers

Internet Marketing

Community Involvement

Juvenile Diabetes Research Fund
Scituate Housing Authority Member
Community Preservation Commission Member
Scituate Little League
Scituate Harbor Yacht Club
Hatherly Country Club

Areas Covered


Professional Association

National Association Of Realtors
Massachusetts Association Of Realtors
South Shore Realtors
Multiple Listing Service
Zillow Area Experts

In The News

Scituate Mariner
Scituate Mariner - Home of the Week

  • Dear Jodi, Jill & Courtney We cant thank you enough for keeping us navigated thru this crazy journey of selling and buying a home. It certainly helps to have pros like you. We feel like we have gained some great friends & great real estate agents. With love & gratitude, Kathy & Gareth Kathy & Gareth (Marshfield)

  • Jodi, Jill & Courtney, How do not even know where to begin. If it wasn't for you the three of you I would never be in the house of my dreams! Thank you for all your guidance, occasional "gentle pushes" to get both houses on the market and much needed help with interior design choices. Endless... Alan & Nicole (Scituate)

  • Dear Jodi, Jill & Courtney, I wanted to express my thanks and appreciation for all your efforts to help me to part with my beautiful home. I feel so fortunate to have had your help and guidance, encouragement and patience in selling my home. Creatively, diligence ad good humor were above and beyo... Catherine (Scituate)

  • Dear Jill, Jodi & Courtney, Your professionalism is always appreciated and we can not thank you enough for selling our home in one day. It was a pleasure working with you, Nancy & Ralph Nancy & Ralph (Scituate)

  • Jodi, Jill & Courtney, Thank you so much for your help over the last few years and for helping us finally find the one! We are settling in and loving our new neighborhood. Thank you for sticking with us! Lauren & Peter Peter & Lauren M (Scituate)

  • Dear Courtney, Jodi & Jill, Thank you for all of your time, effort and patience over the past several months in helping us find our perfect home. We feel so blessed to have found our perfect home, it is truly perfect for us. We love getting to know you and are so lucky to have gotten the chance t... Jess & James C (Marshfield)

  • Dear Jill, Jodi & Courtney, You all were a joy to work with, guiding us along the way. The ending was bittersweet but all in all we had a good run. It was a special home for us for over 35 years but its time had come. Jill, you sold this house as only a fellow Minot resident could. Best of luc... Pat L (Minot)

  • Dear Jill, Jodi & Courtney, Love & many thanks for all your help & guidance both professionally & personally. I couldn't have made this journey without you all. Love, Sara Sara S (Scituate)

  • Jodi, Jill & Courtney, How can we thank you all for being so patient & kind in helping us find our dream home? We absolutely love it here and cant wait to decorate and have you over to see everything we have done. We appreciate all that you have done for us and hope to see you soon! Love, ... Sammy & Jeff (Scituate)

  • Thank you so much for all your hard work in finding me the perfect home. What a wonderful place to live. With heartfelt gratitude, Sincerely, Maureen Maureen (Scituate)

  • The reputation of the Neagle/Caffrey Team preceded them but it was their continual hard work when challenges arose, and their diligent attention to the smoothness of the process, and their compassionate readiness to help in all sorts of ways, that made the project of selling our childhood home -- a ... Tom M. (Scituate, MA)

  • You were always caring and understanding during the months when the house was on the market and ever ready to take charge and get necessary things done and done on time. It never mattered what the glitch was (like recently washed clothes left unfolded on the bed, light bulbs that needed to be replac... Dick C (Cohasset, MA)

  • Courtney is extremely knowledge about the real estate market in the South Shore and also very professional in her demeanor. She sold our house for asking price within a matter of days and found my husband and I our dream house. We couldn't be happier! I would highly recommend Courtney Durkin and ... Pam C (Scituate, MA)

  • Jill and Courtney both made the process incredibly easy, while still providing the level of detail you want when making a significant investment. Erik K (Scituate, MA)

  • Amazing, thoughtful agent who always had my interests at her forefront! Michael C (Hanover, MA)

  • On the buying side, The Neagle/Caffrey team always took the time to put our needs and desires for a new home first to everything. On the selling end, they made selling our house a top priority, as they knew buying our new house was contingent on selling our home. They were fully invested at all time... Justin M (Cohasset, MA)

  • Jodi from Raveis was incredible! She kept me informed every step of the way and went above and beyond with all of the final details that needed to be attended to. Patricia S (Braintree, MA)

  • The sale and purchase of our home was a stressful time for my family. Courtney Durkin was always available whenever we had questions, and was amazing following up with our concerns throughout the process. Chris B. (Scituate, MA)

  • Courtney was a tremendous help to us in our accelerated move to Scituate! It was July and we decided last minute to relocate before the next school year was to start in September. It was a bit insane but Courtney kept her wits about her and helped us every step of the way. We fell in love with the ... Kristi Sullivan (Scituate, MA)

  • Jodi could not have been any better. She was patient, responsive, knowledgeable, insiteful and perfection. She stuck with us almost two years as we worked thru the process of finding our own little piece of heaven. Lori Brightman (Scituate, MA)

  • Courtney had deep knowledge of the existing market that enabled us to find the homes that met our criteria and personality. She was extremely responsiveness and it felt like we were her only customer during our house search. Jeff Anderson (Scituate, MA)

  • Jill and Jodi were outstanding agents along with the rest of the team. They were quick on the communication and helped guide us through the home purchase process professionally and courteously! We are so happy to have worked with them. Matthew Winn (Scituate, MA)

  • Courtney was so pleasant to work with! She knows the area extremely well and understands the needs of her clients very quickly, which made it efficient when showing us houses. She was extremely responsive and truly made us feel like we were her only clients at the time. We would definitely recomme... Stephanie Schilling (Scituate, MA)

  • I first met Jodi when I was searching for temporary housing for our move to Scituate. I found her honest and diligent in her efforts to help me locate suitable housing for my family. Fast forward several months and we had not found a home to buy and were in a situation wh... Joanne T (Scituate, MA)

  • Worked with Jill selling our Scituate home. She has excellent knowledge of the area and guided us in pricing the home at the right value, leading to an immediate sale. She handled the whole process expertly and responded to any questions or concerns almost immediately. She even went above and be... Rosalie P (Scituate, MA)

  • Jill is a phenomenal realtor. Her knowledge of real estate and ability to negotiate are second to none. It also doesnt hurt that shes very friendly and professional making what can be a difficult process as painless as possible. Eric Edelman (Norwell, MA)

  • Working with Jill was excellent experience. We have a two year old so finding time to get out and look at houses is not always easy. She worked with our schedule and was extremely flexible. We were very impressed with her overall market knowledge and home buying process expertise. She was alway... Kate Milmoe (Scituate, MA)

  • Was helpful in all aspects of two transactions - both the sale of our prior home and the purchase of our current one. She also was responsive as far as recommending local resources to help with moving, etc. Jill has been involved in the local real estate business for many years and her experience w... Bill D (Scituate, MA)

  • Jill Caffrey listed and sold our house. Jill knows the market and inventory in Scituate and the surrounding towns better than anyone. She has been in real estate for 20+ years. She knows what houses are selling for in the different neighborhoods and her home appraisal was accurate. Jill is easy ... Brenda Sportack (Scituate, MA)

  • Jill has great expertise and knowledge of the South Shore real estate market. She has helped us evaluate, list and promote our home in Scituate and was a great pleasure to work with. If you're looking to sell your home on the South Shore, I recommend Jill!" She is a true professional! Peter & Bet...

  • Many, many thanks to The Neagle/Caffrey Team with William Raveis Real Estate - Scituate Harbor! Your expertise and professionalism was invaluable to the sale of my home and helping me identify my new home. And you held my hand every step of the way! Ann Kelly (15 Fairoaks Lane Cohasset)

  • Jill Caffrey's experience was invaluable during our home sale. Although our house went under agreement within a week of the listing, we experienced complications with our buyer's buyers. The sale was a contingent sale and this led to issues. Jill worked with all parties and actually was instrument... Maureen Sullivan (Scituate/Plymouth, MA)

  • Jill was wonderful to work with. She had the listing on the house I purchased. I bought it through her and her sister directly. She was so nice and very professional. She has even followed up with me months after the sale to see how I like the house. I highly recommend her Karl M (Scituate, MA)

More Testimonials ›


Your Insurance Rep.

Christine McBride
Insurance NPN#
Cell - 339.832.1759

Email Insurance Rep. › Insurance Quote ›

Your Loan Officer

Julian Hernandez
NMLS Mortgage Loan Originator ID 1800704
Cell - 617.257.3887

Email Loan Officer › Loan Quote ›