Price Reduced 18.28 %

$3,800,000 ($1,594.63 per sqft)

Est. Mortgage $21,256/mo *

Quick Pre-Approval

Price History



3200 HIGEL AVENUE, Siesta Key, FL, 34242

3200 HIGEL AVENUE, Siesta Key, FL, 34242

4 beds

2 Full / 1 Half baths



2,383 sqft

New price! Build your dream home in paradise. Tucked away on a private lane on the northern tip of Siesta Key, positioned on Sarasota’s Big Pass at the mouth of the Gulf of Mexico, is the Blue Lantern, a historic Sarasota location. Offered for the first time in decades, a rare opportunity to build on this waterfront. Offering one of the area’s most coveted lifestyles, only a few exclusive homesites enjoy this spectacular view. The value is in the land; the next fortunate owner will likely replace the existing vintage home with spectacular new construction. Work with your custom builder, or we can connect you with our preferred builder and architect to fully capture the unique beauty of this special location and view. Seldom is a homesite available with such stunning views of Big Pass, South Lido Beach Park, Bird Key, and mesmerizing bay and city skyline views. A near-perfect spot for the boating enthusiast, Big Pass is renowned for its pristine water quality and deep-water boating access to the Gulf of Mexico. It boasts 190 feet of sailboat water frontage on two sides, including rare Big Pass dockage and Bayou Louise-protected water. The property lends itself to connecting with the environment through boating, paddleboarding, snorkeling, windsurfing, and fishing from your private oasis. Discover dolphins, manatee, and an endless array of fish and waterfowl. Savor colorful sunsets, and at night, enjoy sparkling views of downtown Sarasota, Lido Key and Bird Key. Arguably one of the best locations in Sarasota, this highly desirable North Siesta Key location is minutes to the world-famous powdery white sands of Siesta Key Beach and the crystal azure waters of Siesta Key. The quaint shops and alfresco dining spots of Siesta Village are just minutes away, while the vibrant cultural allure of downtown Sarasota can be found just across the bridge. Considered the cultural gem of Florida’s west coast, you’ll find abundant urban, cultural, and social activities, including fine dining, a world-renowned art museum, galleries, ballet, symphony, opera, theater, and numerous charitable events. Convenient to Sarasota Bradenton International Airport, private aviation, and multiple golf courses. Easy access to Tampa, Naples, and Miami.




Single-family residential








Central Air

Lot Size:




Est. Taxes:





BB/HS Internet Available, Cable Connected, Electricity Connected, Sewer Connected, Water Connected

Lot Description:

FloodZone, City Lot, Irregular Lot, Level

View Description:


Elementary School:

Phillippi Shores Elementary

Middle School:

Brookside Middle

High School:

Sarasota High

Days on Market:


Pet Policy:



Dryer, Refrigerator, Washer

Min Lease Term:

1 Week

MLS #:


Community Info

School Info

Southside Elementary School

Rating: 10/10

Enrollment: 729

Distance: 1.49 Miles

Community Rating:

Brookside Middle School

Rating: 7/10

Enrollment: 754

Distance: 1.95 Miles

Community Rating:

Out-Of-Door Academy

Enrollment: 742

Distance: 2.04 Miles

Community Rating:

Achievement Center (The)

Enrollment: 16

Distance: 2.08 Miles

Community Rating:

Phillippi Shores Elementary School

Rating: 9/10

Enrollment: 789

Distance: 2.2 Miles

Community Rating:

Sarasota High School

Rating: 4/10

Enrollment: 2,142

Distance: 2.25 Miles

Community Rating:

Sarasota Virtual School

Enrollment: 45

Distance: 2.3 Miles

Sarasota Virtual Instruction (Course Offerings)

Enrollment: 0

Distance: 2.3 Miles

Westcoast School For Human Development

Enrollment: 15

Distance: 2.37 Miles

Community Rating:

Suncoast School For Innovative Studies

Rating: 3/10

Enrollment: 375

Distance: 2.44 Miles

Community Rating:

Alta Vista Elementary School

Rating: 5/10

Enrollment: 545

Distance: 2.66 Miles

Community Rating:

Sarasota School Of Arts/Sciences

Rating: 9/10

Enrollment: 750

Distance: 2.7 Miles

Community Rating:

Incarnation Catholic School

Enrollment: 165

Distance: 2.71 Miles

Community Rating:

Riverview High School

Rating: 6/10

Enrollment: 2,606

Distance: 2.79 Miles

Community Rating:

Sarasota Military Academy

Rating: 5/10

Enrollment: 1,378

Distance: 2.88 Miles

Community Rating:

Agape Christian School Of Sarasota

Enrollment: 54

Distance: 3.13 Miles

Saltmeadow School

Enrollment: 17

Distance: 3.41 Miles

Mangrove School of Sarasota

Enrollment: 71

Distance: 3.41 Miles

Brickhouse Academy

Enrollment: 31

Distance: 3.57 Miles

Community Rating:

Wilkinson Elementary School

Rating: 3/10

Enrollment: 511

Distance: 3.6 Miles

Community Rating:


Enrollment: 57

Distance: 3.69 Miles

Sarasota Virtual Academy (Virtual Franchise)

Enrollment: 0

Distance: 3.73 Miles

Sarasota County Technical Institute

Enrollment: 4

Distance: 3.73 Miles

Suncoast Polytechnical High School

Rating: 8/10

Enrollment: 565

Distance: 3.81 Miles

Community Rating:

Tuttle Elementary School

Rating: 4/10

Enrollment: 704

Distance: 3.82 Miles

Community Rating:

Palm Grove Mennonite School

Enrollment: 49

Distance: 3.86 Miles

Community Rating:

Bay Haven School Of Basics Plus

Rating: 6/10

Enrollment: 612

Distance: 4 Miles

Community Rating:

Emma E. Booker Elementary School

Rating: 2/10

Enrollment: 560

Distance: 4.14 Miles

Community Rating:

Gulf Gate Elementary School

Rating: 8/10

Enrollment: 711

Distance: 4.23 Miles

Community Rating:

Booker High School

Rating: 3/10

Enrollment: 1,285

Distance: 4.26 Miles

Community Rating:

Sarasota County Acceleration Academies

Enrollment: 106

Distance: 4.39 Miles

Nur Academy

Enrollment: 25

Distance: 4.4 Miles

Liberty Baptist Academy

Enrollment: 47

Distance: 4.62 Miles

Community Rating:

Hershorin Schiff Community Day School

Enrollment: 252

Distance: 4.63 Miles

Community Rating:

Achievement Center of Sarasota The

Enrollment: 56

Distance: 4.72 Miles

Booker Middle School

Rating: 4/10

Enrollment: 805

Distance: 4.75 Miles

Community Rating:

Ascension Lutheran School

Enrollment: 74

Distance: 4.82 Miles

Community Rating:

Cardinal Mooney Catholic High School

Enrollment: 501

Distance: 4.88 Miles

Community Rating:

Esther's School

Enrollment: 16

Distance: 4.89 Miles

Elevation Preparatory Academy

Enrollment: 67

Distance: 4.94 Miles

St Martha Catholic School

Enrollment: 441

Distance: 5.03 Miles

Community Rating:

St. Mary Academy

Enrollment: 63

Distance: 5.03 Miles

Community Rating:

Mcintosh Middle School

Rating: 6/10

Enrollment: 714

Distance: 5.1 Miles

Community Rating:

Brentwood Elementary School

Rating: 6/10

Enrollment: 655

Distance: 5.12 Miles

Community Rating:

Calvary Chapel School

Enrollment: 106

Distance: 5.23 Miles

Community Rating:

Sarasota Academy Of The Arts

Rating: 6/10

Enrollment: 229

Distance: 5.28 Miles

Community Rating:

Gocio Elementary School

Rating: 6/10

Enrollment: 624

Distance: 5.28 Miles

Community Rating:

Imagine School At Palmer Ranch

Rating: 6/10

Enrollment: 502

Distance: 5.38 Miles

Community Rating:

Sarasota Middle School

Rating: 9/10

Enrollment: 1,244

Distance: 5.58 Miles

Community Rating:

Ashton Elementary School

Rating: 10/10

Enrollment: 1,060

Distance: 5.74 Miles

Community Rating:

The Bridge Sarasota

Enrollment: 29

Distance: 5.86 Miles

NewGate School

Enrollment: 155

Distance: 5.86 Miles

Community Rating:

Sunnyside Mennonite School

Enrollment: 15

Distance: 5.91 Miles

Sarasota Christian School

Enrollment: 408

Distance: 5.99 Miles

Community Rating:

Potter's Wheel Academy

Enrollment: 14

Distance: 5.99 Miles

Fruitville Elementary School

Rating: 7/10

Enrollment: 753

Distance: 6.02 Miles

Community Rating:

Prew Academy

Enrollment: 43

Distance: 6.1 Miles

Community Rating:

The Tabernacle Christian School

Enrollment: 246

Distance: 6.87 Miles

Community Rating:

Foundations Christian Montessori Academy

Enrollment: 110

Distance: 6.88 Miles

Kinnan Elementary School

Rating: 3/10

Enrollment: 643

Distance: 7.24 Miles

Community Rating:

Florine J Abel Elementary School

Rating: 4/10

Enrollment: 526

Distance: 7.49 Miles

Community Rating:

Lakeview Elementary School

Rating: 9/10

Enrollment: 599

Distance: 7.99 Miles

Community Rating:

School Information courtesy of GreatSchools

Walk Score


Listing courtesy of PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY Phone: 941-364-4000