$3,985,000 ($871.23 per sqft)

Est. Mortgage $22,019/mo *

Quick Pre-Approval

9137 MIDNIGHT PASS ROAD, Siesta Key, FL, 34242

9137 MIDNIGHT PASS ROAD, Siesta Key, FL, 34242

3 beds

4 Full baths


Contemporary, Custom

4,574 sqft

Welcome to this exquisite waterfront residence in Siesta Key, Florida, boasting an unparalleled sense of spaciousness with captivating Bay views. Combining the elegance of a luxury penthouse with the convenience of a lock-and-leave condominium, this remarkable home offers a truly unique living experience without the limitations of a Homeowners’ Association (HOA). At three stories tall, with floor-to-ceiling-windows facing Sarasota Bay, this stunning residence truly lives like a beautifully appointed townhome – long on luxury touches yet short on yard and lawn maintenance. The second-floor living area overlooks a quiet stretch of Sarasota Bay with an open floor plan offering two separate living areas and opening onto a balcony that looks out across your private pool and dock to the Bay waters. The modern chef’s kitchen is lined with bespoke custom cabinetry from Village Woodworking, with a Subzero refrigerator and Dacor range and ovens. The third level boasts a light-filled master bedroom with endless views and spacious master bath as well as a guest bedroom with views to match. The entire home is accessible via an elevator, but should you wish, the first floor has been converted into a second master suite that opens directly onto the pool deck. Keep it “as is” or redesign the first-floor living space however you wish. The outdoor living space is truly a water-lover and boater’s paradise, featuring a swimming pool and private boat dock stretching out into the Bay. The seawall is new and the dock itself is equipped with a 13,000 lb. lift; able to accommodate up to a 30 ft boat. In addition to the seawall and dock, recent improvements to the property include impact resistant windows and doors, new HVAC, roof and more. This home is a must-see for anyone seeking the exclusive lifestyle reserved for the lucky few who can live alongside our brilliant South Florida waterways.




Single-family residential

Furnished Remarks:


Laundry Remarks:

Laundry Room




3-car Driveway, Garage Door Opener, Golf Cart Parking, Guest




Central Air



Est. Taxes:



Block, Stucco



Lot Description:

FloodZone, In County

View Description:


Elementary School:

Phillippi Shores Elementary

Middle School:

Brookside Middle

High School:

Sarasota High

Days on Market:




Pet Policy:



Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Microwave, Range, Refrigerator, Washer


In Ground

Min Lease Term:

1 Week

MLS #:


Community Info

School Info

Victory Baptist Academy

Enrollment: 56

Distance: 2.59 Miles

Gulf Gate Elementary School

Rating: 8/10

Enrollment: 711

Distance: 3.15 Miles

Community Rating:

Saltmeadow School

Enrollment: 17

Distance: 3.34 Miles

Mangrove School of Sarasota

Enrollment: 71

Distance: 3.34 Miles

Imagine School At Palmer Ranch

Rating: 6/10

Enrollment: 502

Distance: 3.82 Miles

Community Rating:

Sarasota Virtual Instruction (Course Offerings)

Enrollment: 0

Distance: 4.54 Miles

Sarasota Virtual School

Enrollment: 45

Distance: 4.54 Miles

Riverview High School

Rating: 6/10

Enrollment: 2,606

Distance: 4.61 Miles

Community Rating:

Sarasota Virtual Academy (Virtual Franchise)

Enrollment: 0

Distance: 4.88 Miles

Sarasota County Technical Institute

Enrollment: 4

Distance: 4.88 Miles

Phillippi Shores Elementary School

Rating: 9/10

Enrollment: 789

Distance: 4.89 Miles

Community Rating:

Out-Of-Door Academy

Enrollment: 742

Distance: 4.89 Miles

Community Rating:

Sarasota Middle School

Rating: 9/10

Enrollment: 1,244

Distance: 4.9 Miles

Community Rating:

Suncoast Polytechnical High School

Rating: 8/10

Enrollment: 565

Distance: 4.98 Miles

Community Rating:

Ashton Elementary School

Rating: 10/10

Enrollment: 1,060

Distance: 5.17 Miles

Community Rating:

NewGate School

Enrollment: 155

Distance: 5.19 Miles

Community Rating:

Wilkinson Elementary School

Rating: 3/10

Enrollment: 511

Distance: 5.2 Miles

Community Rating:


Enrollment: 57

Distance: 5.23 Miles

Prew Academy

Enrollment: 43

Distance: 5.48 Miles

Community Rating:

Hershorin Schiff Community Day School

Enrollment: 252

Distance: 5.61 Miles

Community Rating:

Incarnation Catholic School

Enrollment: 165

Distance: 5.83 Miles

Community Rating:

Brookside Middle School

Rating: 7/10

Enrollment: 754

Distance: 5.9 Miles

Community Rating:

The Study Center

Enrollment: 4

Distance: 6.32 Miles

Community Rating:

Brickhouse Academy

Enrollment: 31

Distance: 6.42 Miles

Community Rating:

Southside Elementary School

Rating: 10/10

Enrollment: 729

Distance: 6.53 Miles

Community Rating:

Brentwood Elementary School

Rating: 6/10

Enrollment: 655

Distance: 7 Miles

Community Rating:

Sarasota Suncoast Academy

Rating: 7/10

Enrollment: 670

Distance: 7.02 Miles

Community Rating:

Lakeview Elementary School

Rating: 9/10

Enrollment: 599

Distance: 7.19 Miles

Community Rating:

European Academy Of Early Education

Enrollment: 53

Distance: 7.2 Miles

Community Rating:

Palm Grove Mennonite School

Enrollment: 49

Distance: 7.54 Miles

Community Rating:

Sarasota High School

Rating: 4/10

Enrollment: 2,142

Distance: 7.55 Miles

Community Rating:

Alta Vista Elementary School

Rating: 5/10

Enrollment: 545

Distance: 7.56 Miles

Community Rating:

Achievement Center (The)

Enrollment: 16

Distance: 7.56 Miles

Community Rating:

Laurel Nokomis School

Rating: 8/10

Enrollment: 1,181

Distance: 7.62 Miles

Community Rating:

Liberty Baptist Academy

Enrollment: 47

Distance: 7.65 Miles

Community Rating:

Suncoast School For Innovative Studies

Rating: 3/10

Enrollment: 375

Distance: 7.75 Miles

Community Rating:

Ascension Lutheran School

Enrollment: 74

Distance: 7.95 Miles

Community Rating:

School Information courtesy of GreatSchools

Walk Score


Listing courtesy of THE SARASOTA REAL ESTATE COMP. Phone: 941-867-9866